Personal Rank
My Heart List
Where this game lands in my big personal ranking of everything I've played.
- Driven by taste, memories, replay cravings, table stories.
- The most personal and emotional ranking.
One game. Three different lenses. Because favorite, best, and recommended are not always the same thing.
My Heart List
Where this game lands in my big personal ranking of everything I've played.
My Critical Gut Check
A number out of 10. A mix of fun, flaws, replayability, value, and how strongly I'd recommend it.
How Strong I Think It Is
How strong the game is overall, even outside of my personal taste.
Different questions. Different answers. All valid.
I like it, but I reach for other games more.
I had a great time and recommend it highly.
Brilliant design. Excellent at what it tries to do.
It can be 9.5/10. It can be S-Tier. It can still not be #1. That just means another game hits me harder.
Patrons can place opinion stickers anywhere stickers are allowed.
Spirit Island solo
7.5
S
Amazing design, just not my personal craving.
Metroid
7.5
B
Nostalgia carries it high. The score keeps it honest.
Brotato
9.0
A
Near-perfect run. Another game still hits me harder.
S
S: Masterpiece
A
A: Outstanding
B
B: Special and memorable
C
C: Good
D
D: Average
F
F: Poor
10.0
Hall of Fame: Sets a new bar. Rare.
9.0
Outstanding: Special and memorable.
8.0
Great: Strongly enjoyable.
7.0
Good: Enjoyable experience.
6.0
Decent: Worth playing.
5.0
Average: Mixed feelings.
4.0
Below Average: Some issues.
3.0
Poor: Notable problems.
2.0
Bad: Major flaws.
1.0
Unplayable: Avoid outright.
These three rankings work together to give you the full picture. My heart, my head, and my honest recommendation.
Patrons can place opinion stickers anywhere stickers are allowed.
